Afghanistan denies deportation deal with Australia

1019 3

By Afghanistan correspondent Sally Sara | February 01, 2011

There are more than 2,500 Afghan asylum seekers in detention in Australia. (ABc: Brooke Bannister)
The Afghan government has denied an agreement signed with Australia will allow the deportation of unsuccessful Afghan asylum seekers.

Afghanistan signed a deal with Australia and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees two weeks ago, allowing the forced return of failed asylum seekers.

But Afghanistan’s Minister of Refugees Jamaher Anwary now says the memorandum of understanding did not include anything about deportation.

Dr Anwary says reports of unsuccessful Afghan asylum seekers being forced to return home are “poisonous propaganda”.

The Afghan government is under pressure from some human rights groups to scrap the deal because of concerns about the safety of returnees.

Dr Anwary says there is no pressure or force in the protocol and it is against international rules.

The head of the Kabul sub-office for UNHCR, Grainne O’Hara, says the deal does allow for forced returns and the Afghan government knows it.

“I think the Afghan government, having gone through a very lengthy process of negotiation with the Australian Government, is quite fully aware of the terms of the agreement,” Ms O’Hara said.

There are more than 2,500 Afghan asylum seekers in detention in Australia. Forty-nine have had their applications rejected after going through the legal process.

The agreement says it is preferable if failed asylum seekers return to Afghanistan voluntarily and provides assistance if they do. But it still allows for deportation as a last resort.

This is how Immigration Minister Chris Bowen described the significance of the deal when it was signed two weeks ago:

“Never before today has there been an involuntary return from Australia to Afghanistan. So this underlines the importance of today,” he said.

“Without today’s agreement it would be impossible to contemplate involuntary repatriation to Afghanistan.”

But since then, the Afghan government has come under pressure from human rights activists to scrap the memorandum because of concerns about the safety of returnees.

Nader Nadery from Afghanistan’s Independent Human Rights Commission says the Afghan government should never have signed the agreement and will not be able to protect those who are deported.

“Afghanistan is not yet secure and its institutions are not yet capable of providing protection to those who would be sent back to Afghanistan,” he said.

It is unclear whether there is genuine confusion over the detail of the agreement, or if the Afghan government is simply trying to find a way out after receiving a negative response at home.


In this article

Join the Conversation


  1. fredi

    Forced returns are in breach of the UN Convention – and Aus would be shamed before the world if they did it. But can they do it secretly, without anyone knowing? Hazara Australians must make contact with people now in detention – phone them, email them, write cards and letters and support those whose claims of persecution are real and prevent their wrongful deportation – back to danger. You know what waits for people who come back from western countries…

  2. reza

    this year has seen the most number of civilian deaths in afghanistan. how can the racist karzai agree to the forced deportation of poor asylum seekers.

  3. Nasir

    Afghan government is lying – no back bone. If people are found not to be what they say they are then they must go home. Aus government allows a lot more chances than any others. Lying from the moment of arrival and throughout the stay is not the kind of people they want in Aus.